“A French Doll”
by Cynthia Ozick
from the July 31, 2023 issue of The New Yorker
Cynthia Ozick is 95 years old, folks, and here she is with another story for The New Yorker. I don’t think we deserve it, but I’ll gratefully accept! I loved her most recent novella, Antiquities, and I’m glad it wasn’t her last new work.
I always love how I feel I’m in a good hands when I start one of her stories:
The music came down the hall from a door marked 3-C in one of those neighborhood clusters of five-story walkups, which some years later a brutish city planner would raze in favor of an imperial highway. It was not a radio or a needle wobbling on a turntable; it was living notes cascading from piano keys, and it was temperamental. Sometimes it bleated meekly, hesitantly; sometimes it raged, like scales gone berserk. The piano was mainly in need of tuning. Sometimes you heard it, sometimes not. Coming home from school at three o’clock in the afternoon, I would now and then set my knapsack down on the zigzag tile floor in front of that door and listen, not to the music but to its absence. I pressed my ear hard against the peephole until it seemed to me that someone on the other side was breathing, exhaling with an odd little groan—or was it the faint inmost rumble of my own heartbeat? An inch above the peephole was a slot with the name Isidore Atlas.
“A French Doll” is super short, so I’m excited to find the perfect reading space and time to settle in.
I first read this from the actual paper New Yorker. I figured there must be more to take from the story than the widow’s grievance that her husband’s tune was used in a doll without credit and compensation. Certainly someone would enlighten us here… Not even an admission of confusion from anyone!
Last evening I reread the story on the magazine’s site. They mustn’t have wanted anyone to be confused, considering they provided a link, near the beginning of the story, to an interview with the author on the subject of artistic theft. Yup, that was it.
https://www.newyorker.com/books/this-week-in-fiction/cynthia-ozick-07-31-23
Not even a lesson, she says. If there were, “it would be a noisome sermon or tract, and not a small, invented fiction.”
But I’m not convinced. I suspect someone can pull something more out of it that the author missed. Not me this time, though. Just that we shouldn’t let our lives go into decline, being obsessed that we didn’t get our due…