“Prophecy”
by Kanak Kapur
from the January 13, 2025 issue of The New Yorker
I wonder how it must be to be a young writer, publishing a few pieces here and there, no novels or short story collections out just yet, and The New Yorker publishes my story. I’m thrilled when it happens and wish those authors well! Here we have Kanak Kapur’s debut New Yorker fiction, but in looking around I don’t think she’s published much elsewhere. Her interview with Deborah Treisman says she is working on her first novel. So congratulations all around, and I hope we like the story itself.
Here is how “Prophecy” begins:
The night of Dev’s twenty-second birthday, he was invited to sit with the elders after dinner. The summons was conveyed by Bhakti Bai, the maid, who called Dev into the kitchen once the dinner plates had been cleared, and placed in his hands a tray of glasses filled with water. “They’ve asked for you,” she said.
Please feel free to comment below with your thoughts on the story. And Happy New Year, by the way! I hope 2025 is a good year for you all.
I was surprised when the POV changed to first person in the last section. Is there any other stories that do something like that?
Of all the short fiction the New Yorker must get daily, this story somehow was published. It fails on so many accounts: cliched, one dimensional characters, a meandering story line with little intellectual depth, but rather emotional concessions. Skip it and read the engrossing story about copyright infringement.